12/7/2023 0 Comments Examples of meta narrativeBut subconsciously, he holds a deep love for Pakistan that is shown sporadically such as when he visits Manila and feels shameful after comparing its infrastructure with Lahore. In a sense his longingness for the idealism and wealth that America offers is symbolised by his love for Erica. Contrary to the portray of Muslims as singleminded extremists with only the destruction of America and all it stands for in mind, the protagonist Changez is shown as a conflicted character caught between his love of both America and Pakistan. The first method was a bit more manifest and straightforward in nature. Hamid launches a counterattack against the master narrative of 9/11 through his book the Reluctant Fundamentalist through two planes of attack. (Darkly amusingly, the United States killed more civilians in its month long invasion of Iraq than ISIS did in the entire year of 2014. The 9/11 narrative not only established an arbitrary endpoint supported by nonsensical and nonexistent goals, but also lumped humanity into groups of good and bad, famously proclaiming that “If you aren’t with us, you are with the terrorists.” This resulted in not just negative global opinion towards the Americans but also the inability to establish a stable peace in the Middle East. The only reason that Marx’s final stage of communism cannot be disproved is because it’s so far in the unforeseeable future to be even debated. Hegel attempted to argue that Prussia in the 1800’s was the final form of government and end of History back in the 19th century (Insert Holocaust and both World Wars). Francis Fukuyama argued that the modern Liberal democracy was the end point of history (Later retracted). Historical meta-narratives tend to create an endpoint in time, then establish arbitrary phases of history to support their idea of linear thought and change that lead to this endpoint. Meta-narratives such as 9/11 also tend to be too simplistic. What’s next?Īmericans are still trying to find out in 2018. The Americans have defeated the Iraqi and toppled the Hussien regime. God has brought the pious to the Kingdom of Heaven and the sinners are burning in hellfire. The proletariat have gained class consciousness and society has become communism. One of the problem with Meta-narratives like this is “So…… what’s next?”. President Bush even claimed to a senior Palestinian official that “God told me to end the tyranny in Iraq “. So in a way, the 2003 invasion of Iraq could be thought of a neo-crusade by the Godly United States of America against the barbaric and despotic hordes of Iraq. Likewise, the 9/11 narrative portrays the West as the Kingdom of God while the Middle East as Hell. The 9/11 master narrative draws inspiration from Christian doctrine where sinners are cast into hell and the pious brought into the kingdom of God. The 9/11 master narrative, which forms the direct backdrop to the book the Reluctant Fundamentalist, seeks to establish the the legitimacy of the war on terror. President Bush also created a master narrative of his own, which I’ll refer to due to lack of a better name as the 9/11 master narrative. Meta-narratives do not have to be as lofty as to give meaning to history/life but can also be simpler ones that deal with morals and ethics. Marx believed that the meaning of history and existence was so that human society would eventually advance to a stage where everyone had class consciousness and were no longer divided into social classes. Karl Marx explained History through the division of it into 5 phases from Primitive Communism all the way to Communism. A master narrative is the idea that events should be interpreted through a linear fashion in order to give an overarching meaning to existence.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |